OpenOffice.org Forum at OOoForum.orgThe OpenOffice.org Forum
 
 [Home]   [FAQ]   [Search]   [Memberlist]   [Usergroups]   [Register
 [Profile]   [Log in to check your private messages]   [Log in

Help! I’m going crazy over bullets and numbers

 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    OOoForum.org Forum Index -> OpenOffice.org Writer
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
eyolf
OOo Enthusiast
OOo Enthusiast


Joined: 21 Sep 2004
Posts: 102
Location: Denmark

PostPosted: Sun Jun 12, 2005 7:28 am    Post subject: Help! I’m going crazy over bullets and numbers Reply with quote

Over the past few days, I’ve been thrown between Schylla and Charybdis over the topic of numbered/bulleted lists, styles, default settings, connection with outline numbering etc. I think I’ve sorted out some problems, but some remain, and I would love to hear from someone more experienced.

Basically, my questions are:
1. where are the default settings for lists taken from when I make a new list? And how do I make my own default settings in the template?
I want a 10 point offset from bullet to text instead of the 18pt which seems to be default. I can change that in the Format > Bullets/numbers dialog, of course, but then it only applies to that particular list. I've also tried to change it in the standard list formats, and I've created a new paragraph style with numbering on, connected to "List 1" with that positioning set to 10pt, but to no avail - I still have to set it each time through Bullets/numbers.
2. I'm also confounded by the relationship between Outlining and Bullets/numbers. I read in Bruce Byfeld's series (http://www.linuxjournal.com/article/7759) that one should "be careful to include text that uses each of the outline levels have configured. Through some oversight, multi-style outline settings are not preserved in a template unless they actually are used." Is this the case for Bullets/numbers too? At least it seems to be - or maybe I'm wrong - I'm getting confused by all the tests I've made, settings I've changed and re-changed, etc.
The bottom line is, as Byfeld also points out, that the relationship between Outlining and Bullets/Numbers, and the connection with list styles is far from clear, and in some respects flawed.

Part of the problem has probably been related to conversion from Word. I made the mistake of converting a word template to an OOo template and setting it as default. From there on, I got WW8... styles all over the place, and it was impossible to remove them. I ended up making a new template, making all the settings manually, then creating empty docs and pasting in the contents of the converted Word files and the other files that were created from the Word-based template. Only then did i manage to get rid of the WW8... styles.

Any clarification would be welcome - especially concerning the hierarchy of things, and where the default settings are stored.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
ftack
Moderator
Moderator


Joined: 27 Jan 2003
Posts: 3102
Location: Belgium

PostPosted: Mon Jun 13, 2005 12:50 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
1. where are the default settings for lists taken from when I make a new list? And how do I make my own default settings in the template?
I want a 10 point offset from bullet to text instead of the 18pt which seems to be default. I can change that in the Format > Bullets/numbers dialog, of course, but then it only applies to that particular list. I've also tried to change it in the standard list formats, and I've created a new paragraph style with numbering on, connected to "List 1" with that positioning set to 10pt, but to no avail - I still have to set it each time through Bullets/numbers.

The approach using List styles should definitely work and make it to the template. I tried on version 1.9.104.

Quote:
2. I'm also confounded by the relationship between Outlining and Bullets/numbers. I read in Bruce Byfeld's series (http://www.linuxjournal.com/article/7759) that one should "be careful to include text that uses each of the outline levels have configured. Through some oversight, multi-style outline settings are not preserved in a template unless they actually are used." Is this the case for Bullets/numbers too? At least it seems to be - or maybe I'm wrong - I'm getting confused by all the tests I've made, settings I've changed and re-changed, etc.

Very likely, it will be the case for Bullets/Numbering, simply because there some 'factory' default remains in effect no matter what you do. Thus, your custom setings will not even be saved within the document, leave alone in a template. To see this in action, create a list in a doc, customize it using the "Position" and "Options" tabs, create a list on another place, and indeed, you can start again customizing again as you can't save settings from that diolog. Therefore, I strongly recommend never to use Format - Bullets and Numbering again, but instead use List Styles from the "Styles and formatting" (the "stylist") dialog.

Quote:
The bottom line is, as Byfeld also points out, that the relationship between Outlining and Bullets/Numbers, and the connection with list styles is far from clear, and in some respects flawed.


To me, Outlining and Bullets/Numbering are two entirely different numbering systems serving different purposes, and should not be confonded. "Outlining" behaves as if there were only one outlining style, the current one. In other terms, you only can set one format of Outline numbering per document. Format bullet-Numbers behaves as a crippled version of "List styles". Use list styles if you want to work efficiently with lists.

Quote:
Part of the problem has probably been related to conversion from Word. I made the mistake of converting a word template to an OOo template and setting it as default. From there on, I got WW8... styles all over the place, and it was impossible to remove them. I ended up making a new template, making all the settings manually, then creating empty docs and pasting in the contents of the converted Word files and the other files that were created from the Word-based template. Only then did i manage to get rid of the WW8... styles.
You should have been able to delete them using the Stylist, but that would have removed the list formatting alltogether. Your second approach is by far to be preferred.

Quote:
Any clarification would be welcome - especially concerning the hierarchy of things, and where the default settings are stored.


in summary:

Tools - Outline numbering: no hierarchy here: this is the one and single place where you control outline numbering.

Format - Outline numbering: The first four tabs in that dialog allow to quicly apply factory defined settings. There is no way here to save your custom settings. Use "List styles" instead.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
eyolf
OOo Enthusiast
OOo Enthusiast


Joined: 21 Sep 2004
Posts: 102
Location: Denmark

PostPosted: Mon Jun 13, 2005 2:04 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Thanks a lot for your reply. Especially the part about never, ever using Numbers and Bullets again... Smile
ftack wrote:
The approach using List styles should definitely work and make it to the template. I tried on version 1.9.104.

After some more tweaking, it actually seems to be working. For some reason, which I don't quite know why, I seem to have included B/N in the template, so I had to turn it off in order for the correct style of my Pointed list to show. Phew...
Quote:
Very likely, it will be the case for Bullets/Numbering, simply because there some 'factory' default remains in effect no matter what you do. Thus, your custom setings will not even be saved within the document, leave alone in a template.

This sounds like a really bad policy. Now that I'm never ever going to use B/N, it doesn't really matter, though.
Quote:
Therefore, I strongly recommend never to use Format - Bullets and Numbering again, but instead use List Styles from the "Styles and formatting" (the "stylist") dialog.

So B/N should correctly be understood as direct formatting, equivalent to the other formatting commands in that menu, such as italics, which also turns on the "factory" setting "italic text" - but in that case there is only one possible alternative, whereas for a feature like a bulleted list, there are many. This certainly clarifies a lot. (and just as a paragraph style can be defined to contain "italics", so it can also contain bullets).
Quote:
To me, Outlining and Bullets/Numbering are two entirely different numbering systems serving different purposes, and should not be confonded.

I read your response in another thread to Byfeld's article and his somewhat confusing terminology in this respect. Very helpful, even that.
Quote:
You should have been able to delete them using the Stylist, but that would have removed the list formatting alltogether. Your second approach is by far to be preferred.

In the end it worked out, but only through the second method. There was one WW8... style that I could not remove. Writer kept thinking that it was in use, and asked, when I tried to remove it in the Stylist, if I wanted to delete a style that was in use, and I answered "yes", - and nothing happened.
Quote:
in summary:

Tools - Outline numbering: no hierarchy here: this is the one and single place where you control outline numbering.

Although there still is a hierarchy - with the "secret" factory setting as the untouchable top. I don't like untouchable features that interfer with my layout.
Quote:
Use "List styles" instead.

I will - believe me, I will!
Actually, I never used B/N in Word either, since it behaved so erratically, but from the Linuxjournal articles, I got the impression that it was working in OOo, and that it even was a good thing, that one could use in complex ways to create sophisticated results. Hmph...[/quote]
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
ftack
Moderator
Moderator


Joined: 27 Jan 2003
Posts: 3102
Location: Belgium

PostPosted: Tue Jun 14, 2005 1:35 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Glad my lengthy reply was of help Wink Some few additional remarks:

1) N/B is being reworked by hte developpers and will implement saving custom numbering formats from the Format - Numbering Bullets dialog.

2) B/N does actually work very well in Writer! It is only the interface, "Format - Bullets & numbering", and in particular the buttons, that is not what it should be. When you are using List styles, you rely on exactly the same feature, except that you keep all the control. Internally, in the XML format that OOo uses, formatting a list using "format - Numbering & Bullets" is handled in exactly the same way as if you were using Bullet styles. In other words, under the hood, OOo uses List styles as well! Thus, using List styles, you are using the same tools, except that you can save the settings and manipulate them from one central location.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    OOoForum.org Forum Index -> OpenOffice.org Writer All times are GMT - 8 Hours
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group